Source and Credits: XboxAchievements.com
| Mr. Money in the Bank | 70 |
| WWE Universe - Win Money in the Bank using a custom Superstar. (Single play) | |
| Universe Master | 30 |
| WWE Universe - Play and win 50 matches. | |
| Road to WrestleMania | 15 |
| WWE Universe - Win WrestleMania main event as the Royal Rumble winner. (Single play) | |
| Watch out! | 50 |
| Successfully reverse a Finisher. (Single play) | |
| Comeback! | 30 |
| Successfully perform a comeback move. (Single play) | |
| You can't let down your guard | 50 |
| Perform a catch Finisher. (Single play) | |
| A winning combination! | 50 |
| Use a wake-up taunt, land a Finisher, and immediately pin your opponent. (Single play) | |
| Excellent execution | 50 |
| Attack every body part at least once using the limb targeting system. (Single play/Exhibition) | |
| Reached the ropes! | 30 |
| Crawl to the ropes during a submission. (Single play) | |
| Oh! My! | 15 |
| Put your opponent through the announce table via OMG! moment. (Single play/Exhibition) | |
| A winner is you | 70 |
| Win at least 20 matches on Hard difficulty or higher in Universe or Exhibition. (Single play) | |
| Over the ropes you go! | 15 |
| Eliminate 12 opponents with the same Superstar in a single Royal Rumble match. (Single play) | |
| Matchmaker | 15 |
| Win in 20 match variations. (Single play) | |
| Locker room rat | 15 |
| Complete a match with 50 different Superstars/Divas. (Single play) | |
| Unknown veteran | 15 |
| Win 10 times using a custom Superstar. | |
| Tap! Tap! Tap! | 15 |
| Make an opponent tap out with a submission that is not a Finisher or Signature move. (Single Play) | |
| Tragic commentators | 15 |
| Destroy 2 announce tables within a single match. | |
| The ring is my playground | 40 |
| Play a match using a custom arena. (Single play) | |
| One of a kind Superstar | 40 |
| Create a custom Superstar that uses a Superstar head. | |
| 100 bouts | 70 |
| Play 100 matches online. (Ranked matches) | |
| Expert in the ring | 70 |
| Play each different match type. (Ranked matches) | |
| A creator is born | 15 |
| Upload any kind of user created content once. | |
| Austin 3:16 | 15 |
| 2K Showcase - Complete the "Austin 3:16" scenario. (Single play) | |
| Showcase master | 20 |
| 2K Showcase - Complete all Bonus Matches. (Single play) | |
| Wrestling heritage | 30 |
| 2K Showcase - Complete all objectives. | |
| Don't trust anybody | 40 |
| 2K Showcase - Complete all Special Objectives. | |
| Stone Cold said so | 15 |
| 2K Showcase - Unlock and view all video replays and images in the gallery. | |
|
Secret Achievements
|
|
| Phenom vs. Scorpion | 30 |
| WWE Universe - Win a WrestleMania match between Undertaker and Sting. (Single play) | |
| Lightning reflexes | 15 |
| Reverse a curb stomp with the RKO catch Finisher. | |
| Suplex City | 30 |
| With Lesnar, execute "German Suplex 4" or "Back Suplex 2" 10 times in a single match. (Single play) | |
| What? What? What? | 20 |
| 2K Showcase WM19 scenario - Get out of 3 pins during the last Historical Objective. | |
Source and Credits: XboxAchievements.com
