Adam Cole

World Wrestling Entertainment

• 1 NXT Championship
• 1 NXT North American Championship
• 1 NXT Tag Team Championship (with Roderick Strong, Bobby Fish & Kyle O'Reilly - Freebird rule)

Ring of Honor

• 3 ROH World Championship
• 1 ROH World Television Championship

Combat Zone Wrestling

• 1 CZW World Junior Heavyweight Championship

Pro Wrestling Guerrilla

• 1 PWG World Championship

Deams Fighting Entertainment / World Wrestling League

• 1 DFE Openweight/WWL Heavyweight Championship

Eastern Wrestling Alliance

• 1 EWA Cruiserweight Championship

International Wrestling Cartel

• 1 IWC Super Indy Championship

Maryland Championship Wrestling

• 2 MCW Rage Television Championship

New Horizon Pro Wrestling

• 1 NHPW Art of Fighting Championship

Premier Wrestling Xperience

• 1 PWX Heavyweight Championship

Preston City Wrestling

• 1 PCW Cruiserweight Championship

Pro Wrestling World-1

• 1 World-1 North American Championship

Real Championship Wrestling

• 1 RCW Cruiserweight Championship
• 1 RCW Tag Team Championship (with Devon Moore)

WrestleCircus

• 1 WC Big Top Tag Team Championship (with Britt Baker)

WXW C4

• 1 WXW C4 Hybrid Championship

• NXT Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic Winner (2018 - with Kyle O'Reilly)
• NXT Year-End Award - Overall Competitor of the Year (2019)
• NXT Year-End Award - Male Competitor of the Year (2019, 2020)
• NXT Year-End Award - Match of The Year (2019 - vs. Johnny Gargano, 2 out of 3 Falls Match at NXT TakeOver: New York)
• NXT Year-End Award - Rivalry of the Year (2019 - vs. Johnny Gargano, 2020 - vs. Pat McAfee)
• NXT Year-End Award - Tag Team of the Year (2020 - as a member of The Undisputed ERA)
• WWE Bumpy Award - Rivalry of the Half-Year (2021 - vs. Kyle O'Reilly)
• AEW Owen Hart Cup Winner (2022 - Men)
• AEW Dynamite Award - Biggest Surprise (2021 - tied with Bryan Danielson, for their debut at All Out)
• ROH World Championship Tournament Winner (2013)
• ROH Survival of the Fittest Winner (2014)
• ROH World Tag Team Championship #1 Contender Lottery Tournament Winner (2011 - with Kyle O'Reilly)
• PWG Battle of Los Angeles Winner (2012)
• CZW Best of the Best X Winner (2011)
• GBW Battle of Gettysburg Winner (2009)
• IWC Super Indy 16 Winner (2017)
• MCW Shane Shamrock Memorial Cup Winner (2012)
• Pro Wrestling World-1 Shinya Hashimoto Memorial Cup Winner (2010)
• PWI Match of the Decade (2010s - vs. Johnny Gargano at NXT TakeOver: New York)
• PWI Wrestler of the Year (2019)
• PWI Feud of the Year (2019 - vs. Johnny Gargano)
• 2° in the PWI 500 (2020)
• WON Feud of the Year (2019 - vs. Johnny Gargano)
• WON Rookie of the Year (2010)
• CBS Sports Wrestler of the Year (2019)
• CBS Sports Feud of the Year (2019 - vs. Johnny Gargano)
• CBS Sports Match of the Year (2019 - vs. Johnny Gargano, at NXT TakeOver: New York