AJ Styles

World Wrestling Entertainment

• 2 WWE Championship
• 3 WWE United States Championship
• 1 WWE Intercontinental Championship
• 1 WWE Raw Tag Team Championship (with Omos)

Total Nonstop Action Wrestling

• 2 TNA World Heavyweight Championship
• 3 NWA World Heavyweight Championship
• 6 TNA X Division Championship
• 2 TNA Legends/Global/Television Championship
• 2 TNA World Tag Team Championship (1 with Tomko, 1 with Kurt Angle)
• 4 NWA World Tag Team Championship (1 with Jerry Lynn, 1 with Abyss, 2 with Christopher Daniels)

New Japan Pro Wrestling

• 2 IWGP Heavyweight Championship

Ring of Honor

• 1 ROH Pure Wrestling Championship
• 1 ROH Tag Team Championship (with Amazing Red)

Pro Wrestling Guerrilla

• 1 PWG Championship

Revolution Pro Wrestling

• 1 RPW British Heavyweight Championship

All Access Wrestling

• 1 AAW Heavyweight Championship

Ballpark Brawl

• 1 Natural Heavyweight Championship

Christian Wrestling Federation/Entertainment

• 1 CWF/CWE Heavyweight Championship

Family Wrestling Entertainment

• 1 FWE Heavyweight Championship

Independent Professional Wrestling (Florida)

• 1 IPW Heavyweight Championship

Independent Wrestling Association Mid-South

• 1 IWA Mid-South Heavyweight Championship

Independent Wrestling Revolution

• 1 IWR King Of The Indies Championship

International Wrestling Cartel

• 2 IWC Super Indies Championship

Maximum Pro Wrestling

• 1 Max-Pro Cruiserweight Championship

Midwest Pro Wrestling

• 1 MPW Universal Heavyweight Championship

New Korea Pro Wrestling Association

• 1 NKPWA Junior Heavyweight Championship

NWA Wildside

• 1 NWA Wildside Heavyweight Championship
• 3 NWA Wildside Television Championship

Pennsylvania Premiere Wrestling

• 1 PPW Tag Team Championship (with Tommy Suede)

World Wrestling All-Stars

• 1 WWA International Cruiserweight Championship

• WWE Intercontinental Championship Tournament Winner (2020)
• WWE Grand Slam Champion
• WWE Triple Crown Champion
• WWE Slammy Award - Match of the Year (2020 - vs. The Undertaker, Boneyard Match at WrestleMania 36)
• TNA Bound For Glory Series Winner (2013)
• TNA Gauntlet for the Gold Winner (2007 - with Tomko)
• Mr. TNA (2003-2005)
• TNA Feud of the Year (2005 - vs. Christopher Daniels)
• TNA Finisher of the Year (2003 - Styles Clash)
• TNA Match of the Year (2006 - with Christopher Daniels vs. Homicide & Hernandez at No Surrender; 2009) vs. Sting at Bound for Glory)
• TNA Tag Team of the Year (2006 - with Christopher Daniels)
• TNA X Division Star of the Year (2004, 2005)[
• ROH Pure Wrestling Championship Tournament Winner (2004)
• IWA Mid-South's Ted Petty Invitational Winner (2004)
• PWI Wrestler of the Decade (2010's)
• 1° in the PWI 500 (2010)
• PWI Wrestler of the Decade (2010s)
• PWI Wrestler of the Year (2016, 2017, 2018)
• PWI Tag Team of the Year (2006 - with Christopher Daniels)
• PWI Match of the Year (2016 - vs. John Cena at SummerSlam)
• PWI Most Popular Wrestler of the Year (2017, 2018)
• Wrestling Observer Newsletter Hall of Fame induction (class of 2017)
• WON Wrestler of the Year (2015, 2016)
• WON Best Flying Wrestler (2005)
• WON Most Outstanding Wrestler (2014–2016)
• WON Pro Wrestling Match of the Year (2014 vs. Minoru Suzuki on 08/01)
• WON Best Wrestling Maneuver (2003, 2015 - Styles Clash)
• WON United States/Canada MVP (2018)